Hello dear
Welcome to Menemsha Fish Market
Menemsha Fish Market, located in the charming town of Chilmark, is a haven for seafood lovers. Renowned for its exceptional freshness, the market offers a delightful array of catches, from succulent lobsters to juicy oysters, all sourced locally from Edgartown. Visitors rave about the iconic lobster rolls and delectable clam chowder, often highlighting the friendly and knowledgeable staff who enhance the experience. With an inviting atmosphere and unbeatable prices, Menemsha Fish Market not only serves top-notch seafood but also weaves fond memories for families and friends. It's a must-visit for anyone wanting to savor the best of coastal cuisine.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
About
Menemsha Fish Market
Welcome to Menemsha Fish Market, a hidden gem nestled in the charming town of Chilmark, Massachusetts. Located at 54 Basin Rd, this fish market is not just a place to buy fresh seafood; it’s an experience that carries the essence of island life. With friendly staff ready to share their knowledge, Menemsha Fish Market transforms a simple purchase into a delightful culinary journey.
Step inside and you are greeted by the enticing aroma of freshly caught seafood, specifically their world-renowned lobster rolls. As reviewer Aryana Grace passionately puts it, these rolls are addictive, bursting with tender lobster meat enveloped in a perfectly toasted bun. This is just the tip of the iceberg, as the menu offers a variety of prepared and made-to-order items that reflect the freshness of the local catch.
- Fresh Lobster: The highlight here is undoubtedly the fresh lobsters. Brian Tran emphasizes their substantial size and freshness. The knowledgeable staff can guide you through the selection process, ensuring you choose the best for your meal.
- Seafood Delicacies: From the exquisite smoked bluefish pâté to rich and creamy clam chowder, each dish is crafted with care. Jasmine Pitts raves about the lobster bisque, which embodies the sweet flavor of lobster in every creamy spoonful.
- A Taste of Tradition: Merrick Andrews fondly recalls his childhood visits with his family, where the crab cake paddy—a delightful spin on the classic crab cake—was always a favorite.
The atmosphere at Menemsha Fish Market is equally inviting, with staff who are genuinely invested in providing a pleasant experience. Their expertise enriches your visit, as they happily share tips on the best seafood choices and seasonal selections.
Whether you are a local or a visitor, Menemsha Fish Market promises a memorable seafood experience. With unbeatable prices and an array of dishes that showcase the best of what the ocean has to offer, you’ll find yourself returning for more. So, don’t miss out on this culinary oasis; your taste buds will thank you!
Plan your visit today and discover why Menemsha Fish Market is hailed as the best fish market on the island!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ This is the best fish market on the island. Everything is fresh, especially the lobsters, any size you want. Then there are prepared and precooked items as well as made to order plates. Prices are better too. The staff are very friendly and knowledgeable. That gave us a quick primer on what types of lobsters to order, the best season and what to look for to get the best lobster. The smoke bluefish pate is excellent with roasted bread. The lobster fresh and just. The oysters are the freshest we've tasted, large, very juicy and delicious. The price is unbeatable. They are locally caught from Edgartown so don't miss them. ”
“ Best place in Menemsha! Cant wait to come back here. They have the best lobster rolls that im obsessed with and so much more delicious food. Stanley is the sweetest guy! Make’s it coming here an even more pleasant visit. I highly recommend. ”
“ Fresh and tasty lunch!! We tried the lobster rolls, clam chowder and lobster bisque. Everything was delicious and the staff was friendly and helpful. The perfect lunch spot during our trip out here! ”
“ My mom Marty Ann Andrews use to take me here Merrick T. Andrews with my brother Mitchell Edward Andrews to buy fresh fish all the time here, best times on the island but my favorite is the crab cake paddy’s it’s like a crabby paddy but it’s an actual crab cake, it’s really good delicious. ”
“ Stopped by here for some takeout and was seriously impressed! The lobster roll was packed with fresh, tender lobster meat on a perfectly toasted bun. The clam chowder was creamy with a rich flavor. The fresh lobster bisque was buttery, and brimming with that sweet lobster taste. Honestly, I couldn’t pick a favorite—they were all that good! On top of the great food, the people working there were super friendly and helpful. It’s always a bonus when the service matches the quality of the meal. Definitely looking forward to going back and trying more from their menu! Highly recommend for anyone craving top-notch seafood!!! ”
“ So was advised to go here by New Zealand Bill. I met him in a bar in Edgartown drinking Guinness. Always trusting a man and his friends who play drinking games with stout i headed down eh next day. It’s on the docks, they load in the lobsters off the boats and cook them there. I only had the Lobster roll, hot with butter, but it was delicious. One of the best I have tasted. Sat on a concrete pole eating off a cable drum and fighting off the seagulls. Couldn’t have enjoyed it more. ”
“ Fresh seafood, huge clams, friendly owner, nice price. Definitely recommend! ”
“ Menemsha Beach is an absolute must-visit! Grab a hot, buttery lobster roll from Menemsha Fish Market—the best on the island—and settle in to watch the beautiful sunset. The beach offers breathtaking views, making it the perfect backdrop for a memorable evening. Don’t miss this iconic experience, it truly captures the essence of Martha’s Vineyard! ”